Brown sugar pound cake with caramel icing is a rich, moist cake, flecked with toffee bits and smothered in an easy, decadent caramel sauce.
Every June, the extended family of J.’s maternal grandfather gathers at the town community center for a reunion. J. and I have been married a while- seven years to the day as I type this!- so I’ve been to a few reunions.
Last year, I brought this brown sugar pound cake. There’s a relative, Ms. Ruth, who, according to the family, doesn’t eat a lot of sweets. She took a slice of cake, though, and she raved about it. And then she took another slice. I heard, from no fewer than three relatives, how great that cake must be for Ms. Ruth to have two pieces.
This year, a couple days before the reunion, I got word that Ms. Ruth wouldn’t be able to make it, but that she was hoping I would make the brown sugar cake again. She promised me some of her famous chocolate-covered peanut butter sandwich crackers in exchange for a slice.
How could I say no to that? I couldn’t, of course, which is how this cake became a family reunion staple.
brown sugar pound cake with caramel icing
adapted from lady behind the curtain
for the cake
3 sticks butter, softened
2 cups brown sugar
1 cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla
3 cups flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 cup milk
8 oz. bag chocolate toffee bits
for the caramel
14 oz. can sweetened condensed milk
1 cup brown sugar
2 tablespoons butter
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Spray a 12-cup Bundt pan (a 10-cup pan will be too small) with cooking spray. Beat the butter until it’s creamy, and then add the sugars. Beat in the eggs, one at a time, and then the vanilla.
Add the baking powder, salt, and one cup of flour and beat until just combined. Add half the milk and beat until just combined. Alternate adding flour, then the rest of the milk, and then the rest of the flour, mixing each time until just combined. Fold in the toffee bits.
Transfer the batter to the Bundt pan and spread evenly. The pan will be pretty full.
Bake for 70-85 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted near the middle comes out clean. Allow cake to cool for thirty minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool more. Once cake is removed from pan, prepare the caramel sauce by heating sweetened condensed milk and brown sugar in a saucepan over medium heat. Bring mixture to a boil, whisking constantly. Reduce heat and simmer for five minutes, still whisking constantly. Remove from heat and mix in vanilla and butter.
While caramel is hot, spoon it over the cake. You can allow the sauce to cool slightly, but don’t let it cool too much or it will get too thick to spread over the cake. You can use all the caramel on the cake, or you can reserve some to dip fruit in or to serve over ice cream. I used the whole batch on the cake, hence the little caramel pool in the center.
This cake is best served warm, but I can personally attest to its goodness the next day. Or the day after…
What recipe or dish are you always asked to make?
Looking for more decadent sweet treats? These peanut butter cup bars are my husband’s favorite, and my cinnamon roll bars couldn’t be easier or more mouthwatering.
(this post contains affiliate links; to learn more, see my disclosure policy)
This looks so delicious Abby! That icing–WOW. It’s like it posed for the perfect picture 🙂
Thank you! Yes, the icing was very cooperative. And ridiculously delicious.
Lisa Sharp says
This sounds amazing! I’ve pinned it to try later. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you, Lisa! Let me know what you think when you make it!
Stephanie Benton says
Oh my word! I really need to get a bundt cake pan to make this! My husband would LOVE it!
My bundt cake pan was a hand-me-down, but I think it’d definitely be worth the investment!
So I try not to make desserts because only my hubby and I are at home and I’m the one with the sweet tooth (meaning that I eat all the desserts by myself). But still, this looks like something worth breaking the rules for. Thanks for sharing. The pictures are amazing!
Thank you, Kelsie! This is definitely a rule-breaking-worthy recipe! Try my strategy: I give my baked goods away to coworkers, my kids’ teachers, family, neighbors. Share the love!
Rosevine Cottage Girls says
This looks so good!!!!!!
Very Erin says
This looks amazing! I still haven’t gotten the whole baking thing down, but that’s one of my goals when I get a real kitchen!
Thanks, Erin! This wouldn’t be a bad starter recipe- nothing too complicated. I hope you give it a try!
Angela Tolsma says
oh goodness, this looks amazing!
Thank you, Angela!
Wow this looks like something I would need to take a nap after enjoying!
That wouldn’t be a bad choice!
Linda | A La Place Clichy says
This bundt cake looks fannnn-tastic! I just can’t stop looking at that dripping caramel icing! This will be my friend’s birthday cake, that’s for sure!
Thank you, Linda! The caramel is mesmerizing, isn’t it!? I hope you and your friend love it!
Brandy VanDeKop says
This is gorgeous!! My neighbor and I like to try new things and share with each other. I think I will treat her to this! It would be soooo pretty as a Fall dessert, too! Pinning this now!
Thanks, Brandy! Caramel is perfect for fall! You have a very lucky neighbor.
Creatively Homespun says
YUM! Thank you for linking up at the Creative K Kids’ Tasty Tuesdays! I have pinned all your posts to our Tasty Tuesdays Pinterest Board! AND i’ll be featuring this recipe this week! I hope to see you again this week! xo
Thank you! I’ll definitely be there again this week!
Ann S. says
Looks so good. Is the icing at all grainy? I plan to make and was wanting to know how smooth with no graininess the icing is. Thank you Ann
Hi, Ann! I didn’t find the icing grainy at all. It’s nice and smooth. Please let me know how you like the recipe!